IPP Mail Archive: Re: IPP> MOD - new model document with fixes for typos and m

Re: IPP> MOD - new model document with fixes for typos and m

Scott Isaacson (SISAACSON@novell.com)
Fri, 29 May 1998 17:20:44 -0600

Carl - Yes, there is a difference between "request processing" and=20
"job processing". This is what I tried to make clear. Do you agree
with Tom's suggestion, or do we need to do something else.

I propose changing the last word in Tom's new definition to=20

In the case of a Print-Job operation, the
'successful-ok' status code indicates that the request was successfully
received, and validated, and that the Job object has been created; it
does not indicate that the job has been (old: printed) (new: processed).=20=

>>> Tom Hastings <hastings@cp10.es.xerox.com> 05/29 4:53 PM >>>
A simpler clarification fix would be to delete the word "processed"
in "received, validated, processed, ..."

so that it would read:

In the case of a Print-Job operation, the
'successful-ok' status code indicates that the request was successfully
received, and validated, and that the Job object has been created; it
does not indicate that the job has been printed.=20

Tom=20

At 13:28 05/29/1998 PDT, Carl Kugler wrote:
>I question this new definition:
>"13.1.2.1 successful-ok (0x0000)
>"The request has succeeded. In the case of a Print-Job operation, the
>'successful-ok' status code indicates that the request was successfully
>received, validated, processed, and that the Job object has been created; =
it
>does not indicate that the job has been printed. The transition of the =
Job
>object into the 'completed' state is the only indicator that the job has =
been
>printed.
>
>given the definition of 'processing' in section 3.1.7:
>"Job submission time is the point in time when a client issues a create
>request. The initial state of every Job object is the 'pending' or
>'pending-held' state. Later, the Printer object begins processing the =
print
>job. At this point in time, the Job object's state moves to 'processing'.=

>This is known as job processing time. There are validation checks that
must be
>done at job submission time and others that must be performed at job
processing
>time.
>
>I don't believe that successful-ok (0x0000) really indicates that the =
request
>was successfully "processed". Or at least there is the danger of =
confusion
>here between "request processing" and "job processing". Perhaps "request
>processing" needs a definition.
> -Carl
>
>