Dennis,
Yes, an IPPFAX Sender would be required to support redirection, IF an IPP
Sender has to conform to all of the requirements of IPPGET. The overhead
for an IPPFAX Sender is minimal. It just has to look for the status code
that says the Printer is redirecting Get-Notification requests to a Server,
in which case the Sender just tries the Get-Notifications again at the new
URL.
On the other hand, since the IPPFAX protocol has removed REQUIRED operations
from IPP, such as Cancel-Job, it would be possible for the IPPFAX Protocol
spec to rule out the REQUIRED redirection from IPPGET. Hence, my issue.
Tom
-----Original Message-----
From: Dennis Carney [mailto:dcarney@us.ibm.com]
Sent: Monday, January 20, 2003 07:03
To: Hastings, Tom N
Cc: ifx@pwg.org
Subject: Re: IFX> ISSUE: Is IPPFAX protocol with IPPGET going to use the
re-direct mechanism?
Tom,
The way the spec is written, it seems that an IPPFAX Sender would be
required to support redirection in any case.
The spec says (section 2.1):
Statement (sic) of the form "the IPP Client MUST ..." apply if the
client supports the IPPGET Event Delivery Method, since this extension
is REQUIRED if the client supports the IPPGET Delivery Method.
This is more an issue with the spec than with IPPFAX, but isn't it
illegal/impossible to add required extensions?
Dennis
"Hastings, Tom N"
<hastings@cp10.es To: ifx@pwg.org
.xerox.com> cc:
Sent by: Subject: IFX> ISSUE: Is
IPPFAX protocol with IPPGET going to use the re-direct mechanism?
owner-ifx@pwg.org
01/19/03 06:24 PM
Here is an issue I sent out on October 11, but there has been no answer.
ISSUE 05: for the IPPFAX WG, which is REQUIRING support of IPPGET Delivery
Method: Is redirection an option of an IPPFAX Receiver? If yes, then the
IPPFAX Sender MUST support redirection as specified in this document.
The spec which has the redirect mechanism in it is:
[not-srv], "Distributed Notification Service and IPPGET Client Behavior",
Hastings, T., Lewis, H., and I. McDonald, October 10, 2002, work in
progress,
ftp://ftp.pwg.org/pub/pwg/ipp/new_NOT/ipp-dist-not-service-021010.pdf
Thanks,
Tom
-----Original Message-----
From: Hastings, Tom N [mailto:hastings@cp10.es.xerox.com]
Sent: Friday, October 11, 2002 15:14
To: ipp@pwg.org
Cc: ifx@pwg.org
Subject: IFX> NOT - New PWG IPP Distributed Notification Service and
IPPGET Client Behavior available
Ira McDonald, Bob Herriot, Harry Lewis, Carl Kugler, and I have made a
number of passes over the new PWG draft standard 5100.6-D0.1. Its
entitled:
"IPP Distributed Notification Service and IPPGET Client Behavior". It has
the redirection mechanism that was removed from the IETF IPPGET Delivery
Method spec. The conformance requirements for IPPGET clients is unchanged
in this document from what they were in the IETF IPPGET draft. We think
the
redirection mechanism is still very sound from a security point of view,
but
we're being cautious by moving it to this PWG spec, while we send the IETF
IPPGET and Base Notification spec drafts forward to the IESG.
ISSUE for the IPPFAX WG, which is REQUIRING support of IPPGET Delivery
Method: Is redirection an option of an IPPFAX Receiver? If yes, then the
IPPFAX Sender MUST support redirection as specified in this document.
The files are available at:
ftp://ftp.pwg.org/pub/pwg/ipp/new_NOT/ipp-dist-not-service-021010.pdf
ftp://ftp.pwg.org/pub/pwg/ipp/new_NOT/ipp-dist-not-service-021010.doc
Here is the Abstract:
Abstract: This document specifies an OPTIONAL IPP Distributed Notification
Service for use with the "Internet Printing Protocol (IPP): Event
Notifications and Subscriptions" specification (ipp-ntfy). This IPP
Distributed Notification Service enables multiple trusted IPP Printers to
off-load IPP Event Notification Delivery to a shared Notification Server
for
any Event Delivery Method. The Notification Server (instead of the
Printer)
deals with the burden of delivering Event Notifications. For the IPPGET
Delivery Method (get-method), the Notification Server, rather than the IPP
Printer, takes over the burden of keeping a large number of long duration
connections open for outstanding Get-Notifications operations.
This document also specifies additional REQUIRED behavior for any client
supporting the IPPGET Delivery Method.
Conformance: This extension is REQUIRED for all IPP clients that support
the IPPGET Event Notification Delivery Method. This extension is OPTIONAL
for IPP Printers that support the IPPGET or any other Event Notification
Delivery Method.
Ira McDonald has written a companion spec for the protocol between the
Printer and the Notification Server which we will post shortly as another
PWG Draft. Its entitled: "Distributed Notification Service - Printer to
Notification Protocol (PNSP). We briefly considered combining them, but
didn't because using PNSP isn't required in order to redirect the
Get-Notifications request. Also having too many conformant interfaces in a
single document becomes too cumbersome to understand which statements apply
to which interface.
Here are the Changes from the redirection in the original IPPGET Delivery
Method [get-method]:
17.1 Changes from [get-method] to make version 0.1
1. Invented the title: "The Printer Working Group
Standard for
Internet Printing Protocol (IPP): Distributed Notification Service and
IPPGET Client Behavior"
2. Removed this redirection functionality from the
IETF IPPGET
[get-method] specification and put it in this document.
3. Section 2.2: Defined "IPPGET Client",
"Notification Server",
and "Distributed Notification Service" terms.
4. Clarified that this specification is the Interface
between
an IPP Client and a Distributed Notification Service, in case the IPP
Printer exercises the option of using a Notification Server to deliver
Event
Notifications.
5. Section 5.3: Maintained the client requirement to
support
the redirection for any client that supports the IPPGET Event Delivery
Method (see [get-method]). In other words, any client that supports the
Get-Notifications operation is required to support the redirection in case
the Printer exercises this option.
6. Clarified that this Notification Server may
deliver Event
Notifications for any Push Delivery Method and for the IPPGET Pull Delivery
Method.
7. Section 4.1: Added the "printer-notify-server-uri"
(1setOf
uri) Printer Description attribute so that the Printer could be configured
for none ('no-value' out-of-band value), one, or more than one Notification
Server.
8. Sections 5.2 and 6.1: Clarified that the
"redirect-uri"
(uri) operation attribute and the 'redirection-other-site' status code are
for use with the Get-Notifications operation response only, but could be
used by operations defined in the future or existing operations if the IPP
protocol minor version number incremented.
9. Section 5.1: Clarified that the Printer MAY return
the
"redirect-uri" (uri) operation attribute depending on any
implementation-defined reasons which could be dynamically varying. Gave
examples, such as on the number of open channels and the authorization of
the user.
10. Section 7.3: Added conformance requirements for a
Notification Server, acting in combination with a Printer, to provide a
Distributed Notification Service.
11. Section 15: Added the Informative Appendix that
describes
PNSP.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Mon Jan 20 2003 - 16:30:07 EST