Hi,
Please review via email and at upcoming face-to-face.
Attached and appended below (both in plaintext).
Word usage - Ron - the term 'workgroup' (one word) is ubiquitously
used (and automatically suggested in the Google search bar) for
computer and printing environments. The term 'work group' (two
words) is only correctly used in sociology, etc. Please normalize
in the IPP/2.0 spec (both are now used).
Correct draft filename of IPP/2.0 Profiles spec should be:
wd-ipp20-2008mmdd.pdf / doc
Due to travel conflicts, I will NOT be calling into the IPP, WIMS, or
MFD WG sessions at the August face-to-face meeting. Good luck.
Cheers,
- Ira
--
Ira McDonald (Musician / Software Architect)
Chair - Linux Foundation Open Printing WG
Blue Roof Music/High North Inc
email: blueroofmusic at gmail.com
winter:
579 Park Place Saline, MI 48176
734-944-0094
summer:
PO Box 221 Grand Marais, MI 49839
906-494-2434
----------------------------------------------------------
3. Requirements
3.1. Rationale for IPP/2.0
The Printer MIB v2 [RFC3805] and Port Monitor MIB [PWG5107.1] define:
(a) Model of Print Devices
(b) Operations for Print Devices
- prtGeneralReset
- prtConsoleDisable
(c) Groups of simple attributes for Print Devices
- prtInputTable --> prtInputName
- ppmPortTable --> ppmPortServiceNameOrURI
(d) Conformance requirements for implementations of Printer MIB v2
and Port Monitor MIB
The IPP/1.1 Model and Semantics [RFC2911] defines:
(a) Model of Print Services, Print Devices, and Print Jobs
(b) Operations for Print Services and Print Jobs
- Pause-Printer
- Print-Job
(c) Attributes for Print Services and Print Jobs
- printer-location
- job-id
(d) Conformance requirements for implementations of IPP/1.1
The IPP/1.1 Encoding and Transport [RFC2910] defines:
(a) Protocol Bindings for IPP/1.1
- HTTP with optional upgrade to TLS
(b) Mappings of operations for Print Services and Print Jobs
Jobs.
(c) Conformance requirements for implementations of IPP/1.1
Later IETF and PWG standards-track specifications defined 14 IPP/1.1
extensions including:
(a) New operations
- Set-Printer-Attributes [RFC3380]
- Resume-Job [RFC3998]
(b) New attribute syntaxes
- collection [RFC3382]
(c) New objects
- Subscription [RFC3995]
- Document [PWG5100.5]
Current enterprise printers often support functionality standardized in
these IPP/1.1 extensions (in a proprietary manner). In order to support
user requirements for advanced printing functionality, there is a clear
need to standardize profiles of these IPP/1.1 extensions for reliable
interoperability and to encourage adoption of IPP-based infrastructure.
3.2. Use Models
See the definitions of Workgroup Printer, Enterprise Printer, and
Production Printer in section 2 Terminology above.
3.2.1. Workgroup Printer
Alice, Bob, and Charlie are graphic artists who share a workgroup
printer down the hall. They all load paper when needed. Alice and Bob
have convinced Charlie that he should load the toner cartridges. But
they do use many paper sizes - they need PWG Media Standardized Names
[PWG5101.1] used in the IPP 'media' attribute. And they print lots of
thumbnails of graphic images - they need standard IPP document formats.
3.2.2. Enterprise Printer
Joe and his colleagues send large documents to an enterprise printer in
a building across the street in a 'glasshouse' with some web servers.
Both Joe and the operator Sue in the glasshouse manage lots of jobs -
they need to hold and release jobs. Joe wants to keep track of his jobs
- he needs to subscribe for job events. Sue is expected to manage
several printers - she needs to enable and disable printers (i.e.,
enable/disable accepting new jobs over input channels).
3.2.3. Production Printer
Louise works in Accounting for a big wholesaler in Kansas City. She
sends variable data jobs (e.g., different user names, user addresses,
and balance owed amounts formatted onto a pre-printed form) to a
production printer in Chicago. Her friend Sam is a night-shift operator
in Chicago. Sam has to make sure that job resources (e.g., the
pre-printed forms for Louise's jobs) are loaded when needed - he often
needs to pause the printer after the current job.
-------------- next part --------------
3. Requirements
3.1. Rationale for IPP/2.0
The Printer MIB v2 [RFC3805] and Port Monitor MIB [PWG5107.1] define:
(a) Model of Print Devices
(b) Operations for Print Devices
- prtGeneralReset
- prtConsoleDisable
(c) Groups of simple attributes for Print Devices
- prtInputTable --> prtInputName
- ppmPortTable --> ppmPortServiceNameOrURI
(d) Conformance requirements for implementations of Printer MIB v2
and Port Monitor MIB
The IPP/1.1 Model and Semantics [RFC2911] defines:
(a) Model of Print Services, Print Devices, and Print Jobs
(b) Operations for Print Services and Print Jobs
- Pause-Printer
- Print-Job
(c) Attributes for Print Services and Print Jobs
- printer-location
- job-id
(d) Conformance requirements for implementations of IPP/1.1
The IPP/1.1 Encoding and Transport [RFC2910] defines:
(a) Protocol Bindings for IPP/1.1
- HTTP with optional upgrade to TLS
(b) Mappings of operations for Print Services and Print Jobs
Jobs.
(c) Conformance requirements for implementations of IPP/1.1
Later IETF and PWG standards-track specifications defined 14 IPP/1.1
extensions including:
(a) New operations
- Set-Printer-Attributes [RFC3380]
- Resume-Job [RFC3998]
(b) New attribute syntaxes
- collection [RFC3382]
(c) New objects
- Subscription [RFC3995]
- Document [PWG5100.5]
Current enterprise printers often support functionality standardized in
these IPP/1.1 extensions (in a proprietary manner). In order to support
user requirements for advanced printing functionality, there is a clear
need to standardize profiles of these IPP/1.1 extensions for reliable
interoperability and to encourage adoption of IPP-based infrastructure.
3.2. Use Models
See the definitions of Workgroup Printer, Enterprise Printer, and
Production Printer in section 2 Terminology above.
3.2.1. Workgroup Printer
Alice, Bob, and Charlie are graphic artists who share a workgroup
printer down the hall. They all load paper when needed. Alice and Bob
have convinced Charlie that he should load the toner cartridges. But
they do use many paper sizes - they need PWG Media Standardized Names
[PWG5101.1] used in the IPP 'media' attribute. And they print lots of
thumbnails of graphic images - they need standard IPP document formats.
3.2.2. Enterprise Printer
Joe and his colleagues send large documents to an enterprise printer in
a building across the street in a 'glasshouse' with some web servers.
Both Joe and the operator Sue in the glasshouse manage lots of jobs -
they need to hold and release jobs. Joe wants to keep track of his jobs
- he needs to subscribe for job events. Sue is expected to manage
several printers - she needs to enable and disable printers (i.e.,
enable/disable accepting new jobs over input channels).
3.2.3. Production Printer
Louise works in Accounting for a big wholesaler in Kansas City. She
sends variable data jobs (e.g., different user names, user addresses,
and balance owed amounts formatted onto a pre-printed form) to a
production printer in Chicago. Her friend Sam is a night-shift operator
in Chicago. Sam has to make sure that job resources (e.g., the
pre-printed forms for Louise's jobs) are loaded when needed - he often
needs to pause the printer after the current job.